Episode 15 · 2026-10-09
You Have Data. Why Can't You Decide?
Analysis got cheap and options are nearly free, yet the decision still sits there, because nobody's objectives arrive any faster.
Decision engineer Michelle Florendo on why more data has not made deciding easier: the hard part was never the options or the information, it is knowing what you want and counting the data that never reaches a dashboard.
Host Sam Rogers · guest Michelle Florendo, the decision engineer · 27 min
A choice this episode can help with
What do you actually want from the decision you are sitting on?
The short answer: Analysis got cheap but objectives didn't get faster, so deciding is the real job: name what we want, count the feelings as data, and don't treat the most rational option as the best.
Run it on your own work: The Concern Column, one page, any model.
Watch it below, or read the conversation.
Jump to a moment
- 2:04 As we offload the doing, the deciding matters more
- 9:56 Analysis got cheap, objectives did not get faster
- 12:35 Friction, conflict and what keeps decisions stuck
- 18:57 Decision quality is not the same as the outcome
- 20:28 The assumption that good decisions must be purely rational
- 25:57 This week: write down what we want before asking anyone
Listen
Or follow the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or in any podcast app.
The signals
- Michelle: As we offload the doing, the deciding matters more. "As we're offloading the doing, the deciding becomes more important,". A senior tech leader she coaches noticed the way his teams made decisions had to change. Her frame comes from Professor Ron Howard: every decision has three parts. Objectives are the compass, options are the leg where people fall into a binary, and information is the leg that gives people the most feelings, since "waiting for certainty is a decision in itself."
- Sam: Analysis got cheap, and objectives didn't get faster. "AI has made the analysis part really cheap," so much so that deciding is basically the real job now. Options and information, two legs of Michelle's stool, are nearly free, "but nobody's objectives necessarily arrive any faster." That's what shaped the episode's takeaway, a successor to the pros-and-cons list, which Michelle points out is more than two hundred years old: "We can upgrade our tools for decision making." Sam ran it on a real decision about his own business that morning.
The subtractions
- Michelle: Subtract the idea that good decisions must be purely rational. She works with cerebral people who tell her they need to be rational, and her answer is a question: "can I call you out on like this assumption you're making that like good decisions must be purely rational?" Risk often surfaces as an emotion, so name it: fear of a business no longer being viable is different from fear of being embarrassed. Her line to keep: "it's more important to be resilient than to be right."
- Sam: Stop using AI simply as a rational advisor. "Just because it's the most rational choice doesn't mean that it's the best choice." A model has no access to the physical feelings Michelle described; Sabino Marquez made the same point on Episode 4, safety is a feeling in the body. Michelle's button on it: "good decisions need to make sense but also feel right," and "you can't calculate your way to trust."
About this episode
The thread through the episode is the one Sam opened with: we have more information than ever, and the decision still sits there. What's missing isn't data. It's the objectives nobody wrote down and the concerns nobody counted, and Michelle's case is that both are learnable skills, which she calls decision fluency.
Markus Bernhardt sent in a question from the livestream: how do you get people to frame the question before they see any options? Michelle's answer is that framing comes before all three legs. It's the fourth part of Decision Quality, the red book on her shelf that's popular with the Society of Decision Professionals, and leading with options gives you a narrow frame. Sam added the framing assumption he sees most: that a good process will insulate you from a bad outcome, which rolls decision quality and outcome quality into one thing.
One thing to do this week: pick one decision you're sitting on. Before you ask anybody, or any disembodied agent, for the pros and cons, write down what you actually want from it. Then for each option, write down what concerns you and where you feel it, and whether that points to something you want that isn't on your list yet. That's the part no amount of data will give you.
Links from the episode:
- Decision Fluency: Michelle's Substack, the one place she asked listeners to go
- Ask a Decision Engineer: her podcast, back for its seventh season this month
- Powered by Decisions: her practice
- The Concern Column: the episode's takeaway, built on her Pro-Con List With A Twist
- Earlier episodes Sam called back to: Episode 14 with Limited Edition Jonathan for the AI deep end, Episode 12 with Omar Ladak on objectives, Episode 7 with Douglas Hubbard on information, and Episode 4 with Sabino Marquez on safety as a feeling
Books Michelle pulled off her shelf: Decision Quality, and Annie Duke's Thinking in Bets. As an Amazon Associate, Snap Synapse earns from qualifying purchases made through the book links on this page.
Want to bring your own signal and subtraction? Find yours.
Transcript
Read the conversation
Michelle Florendo: I see a lot of people say, I need to make a good decision here, I need to be rational about it. And I'm like Okay, and can I call you out on this assumption you're making that good decisions must be purely rational?
Sam Rogers: Welcome to Signals and Subtractions. I'm your host, Sam Rogers. You have data, so why can't you decide? That's the question of the day. Most of us have more information than we've ever had: reports and dashboards and a model that will hand us 10 options and a cited brief in a minute or less now. So still the decision sits there. Or it gets made and then remade and then second guessed? So today I have brought in someone whose whole job is helping facilitate the deciding part. Michelle Florendo is a decision engineer and facilitator. She's the founder of Powered by Decisions, and she's trained in decision science at Stanford. She's coached leaders at some of the biggest companies you know. She's also the host of her own podcast, Ask a Decision Engineer, back for its seventh season later this month. Very excited to have you here, Michelle. Welcome.
Michelle Florendo: I'm excited to be here and excited for this conversation.
From Michelle Florendo
Put it to work
Pick one decision you're stuck on. What concerns you about each option, and what does that concern say you actually want?
The newsletter
Issue 72 · Sunday 11 October 2026 · sent on Substack and LinkedIn.
One signal, one subtraction, one analogy, in five minutes. It draws on this episode but stands on its own. Every issue.
The method from this episode is one page with its copy-paste prompt and schema: The Concern Column, linked under the decision above. Every takeaway.
Keep the next choice in view
One signal, one subtraction and one analogy every Sunday. Five minutes, no video required.
Optional. Free on Substack, no account needed. Already on LinkedIn? Subscribe there.